Home Resources Our blog Help! My Medicare Supplement Application Was Denied!
Medicare Supplement (Medigap)
Feb 2, 2023

Help! My Medicare Supplement Application Was Denied!


Dear AMAC,

I never thought about changing my Medigap until recently since my premium has skyrocketed. I met with a local agent who helped me apply for the same plan but with another company whose premiums were much lower, but last week I got a letter saying my application was denied for a health condition that I don’t even have! Should I give up on trying to apply or can I fight this?

-Dean (West Palm Beach, FL)

Hello Dean,

Being denied coverage is a frustrating experience, especially if the grounds for denial were unfounded. The good news is that you can appeal this decision, but it will cost you some time and effort.

First and foremost, be sure to read that denial letter thoroughly as it will have several important pieces of information on it. Denial letters are not typically shared with your insurance agent for privacy purposes, so there are some steps you may have to take on your own to get the appeals process going.

The letter will include a description of what prompted the insurance company to issue the decline and how long you have to appeal the decision. Do contact the appeals department as soon as possible since this can be a lengthy process. In some instances, you may have to contact your physician to obtain a statement or have them update your medical records.

As you gather the documentation needed, make copies just in case anything gets lost. Each time you call in, be sure to ask what else is needed of you, what the timelines are, and when they will make a final decision. Take detailed notes of who you spoke with and when- this will help you stay on top of the process and hold them accountable to their timelines.

Keep in mind that the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) requires companies to look over your appeal and resolve it within 30 days. The resolution does not guarantee that they will ultimately accept your insurance application, but they may change their decision if there is sufficient evidence that you were wrongly denied.

If the appeal is denied, you can always try to apply with a different insurance company, but keep in mind that they will still see the negative items on your report if you were not able to get them removed. I wish you the best of luck with everything, Dean. I hope this helps!

Your Medicare Advisor

For help with Medicare plans – or any questions you may have about Medicare – contact AMAC’s Medicare Advisory Service at 1-855-611-4856 or request a quote below!

(Please note that we do not offer every plan available in your area. Any information we provide is limited to those plans we do offer in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE to get information on all of your options.)

Get a Quote Here!

Share this article:

Shop and compare Medicare Advantage plans now

Related Blog Articles
older couple on computer for medicare annula enrollment period
Enrollment Periods
// Nov 2, 2023

Which changes can I make during the Annual Enrollment Period?

If you watch TV or listen to the radio, you’ve certainly heard all the chatter abou...
Read more
american flag with thank you veterans sign
// Nov 11, 2023

Honoring our Veterans this Veteran’s Day

As Veteran’s Day approaches, we give thanks to the 19 million brave men and women w...
Read more
medicare drawing to make sense of medicare advantage plans
Medicare Advantage (Part C)
// Nov 16, 2023

Making sense of Medicare Advantage Plans

Original Medicare consists of two parts; Part A which is Hospital coverage, and Part ...
Read more
scammer phone call during open enrollment for medicare
Enrollment Periods
// Nov 30, 2023

Avoid Scams During Medicare Open Enrollment – and All Year!

As the annual Medicare open enrollment period draws to a close, there are still scamm...
Read more